Welcome to the PlainfieldCS Forum. You will need to log in before you can post here. Click here to log in if you already have an account. If you do not have an account, please contact jeremy@plainfieldcs.com. Thank you!


"A Truth That's Told With Bad Intent"

The Forum is dedicated to each week's lesson, and may be used to post questions, comments, and constructive replies that strive to uncover the inspired meaning of the text. The Bulletin Board is for gratitude for Christian Science and the Church, as well as timely excerpts from the Bible, the works of Mrs. Eddy, and the early workers that help and encourage. We are very grateful for all posts that conform to these guidelines, but will edit or remove anything that the Practitioners feel is not in complete accord with pure Christian Science or in any way disrespectful of it.

We also ask that you keep your postings as concise as possible; make two short postings of the long posts or send the lengthy ones for publication in our Magazine or Newsletter. If you quote the Bible, please use The King James Version, as this is what Mrs. Eddy used. Thank you!


Announcements Forums Truth – July 22nd, 2018 "A Truth That's Told With Bad Intent"

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #6900
    parthens
    Participant

    Quite a number of commentaries agree that it was Miriam who spoke these ambitious words against Moses: “Hath the Lord indeed spoken only by Moses? hath he not spoken also by us?” But Aaron certainly did not argue with her in the least.

    To belittle Moses was to make others perceive him to be smaller than he truly was, or to paraphrase Laura Riding, to rob him of size. So it is not surprising that error would seize upon Moses’ marrying a Gentile instead of one of the daughters of Abraham.

    But whether Moses sinned or not is irrelevant here. Even if his accusers were correct, technically speaking (and this point is moot, indeed), the aphorism of William Blake fits well here:

    “A truth that’s told with bad intent
    Beats all the lies you can invent.”

    For this reason, Miriam’s and Aaron’s self-congratulatory belittling of Moses prefigures modern-day articles and books endorsed by the Boston CS establishment that deliberately underestimate the size of Mrs. Eddy’s monumental significance and stupendous achievements.

    #6901
    Susanne
    Participant

    Thank you for this post. I hadn’t heard this aphorism before. It reminds me of situations when the WHOLE truth would have been truly helpful, instead of just a partial truth. Sometimes what is OMITTED would have been the missing piece to save a lot of grief. BUT, that means facing the situation, and isn’t it more expedient for some to kick the can down the road, or just be lazy? But when the problem surfaces down the road, as they tend to do, things are worse. Which is why I love Mrs. Eddy’s statement, “Honesty is spiritual power.” (S&H p. 453) And also, “When needed tell the truth concerning the lie. Evasion of Truth cripples integrity, and casts thee down from the pinnacle. … A dishonest position is far from Christianly scientific. “He that covereth his sins shall not prosper: …” (S&H p. 448). The warnings are all there!

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.


Love is the liberator.